WHEELS OF JUSTICE: ANALYSING THE LEGAL STATUS OF AUTONOMOUS VEHICLES IN CONTEMPORARY LEGAL REALM

Smriti Rai; Deepak Kumar Chauhan; Dharmendra Kumar Kumawat

doi:10.29121/shodhkosh.v4.i2.2023.1754

Authors

Smriti Rai Research Scholar (JRF Fellow), Department of Law, School of Legal Studies Central University of Punjab, Punjab, India
Dr. Deepak Kumar Chauhan Professor, Department of Law, School of Legal Studies, Central University of Punjab, Punjab, India
Dharmendra Kumar Kumawat Research Scholar (ICSSR Fellow), Department of Law, School of Legal Studies Central University of Punjab, Punjab, India

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.29121/shodhkosh.v4.i2.2023.1754

Keywords:

Artificial Intelligence, Autonomous Vehicles, Legal Personhood, Agency Law, Product Liability

Abstract [English]

The research paper examines the complex legal issue of determining the status of autonomous vehicles (AVs) as an independent legal entity or an agent of the manufacturer. The paper delves into the concept of legal personhood and its application to artificial intelligence (AI) systems, including AVs. It explores various theories of legal personhood, such as the Natural Law Theory, Will Theory, and Function-based Theories, and their relevance to the classification of AVs. The paper also discusses the theory of agency law and its potential implications for the relationship between AVs and their manufacturers or developers. The paper analyzes the current Indian legal framework, including the Motor Vehicles Act and the Consumer Protection Act, and their limitations in addressing the legal issues posed by AVs. It highlights the ambiguity in liability determination, particularly in the case of partially automated vehicles, where the role of the human driver and the AV's decision-making process must be carefully considered. The paper proposes a hybrid approach to the legal status of AVs, combining elements of both independent legal personhood and agency of the manufacturer. The paper emphasizes the need for comprehensive and adaptable legislation to address the evolving landscape of autonomous vehicle technology and ensure the safety and accountability of these systems. It acknowledges the complex and rapidly changing nature of automated vehicle technology and calls for further research and discussion to develop a robust legal framework that can effectively govern the integration of AVs into India's transportation ecosystem.

References

Arman, A. D. (2020). The Wild, Wild West : A Case Study of Self-Driving Vehicle Testing in Arizona. Arizona Law Review, 983-985.

Bayern, S. (2015). The Implications of Modern Business Entity law for the Regulation of Autonomous Systems. Stanford Technology Law Review, 104-106.

Buxbaum, P. R. (n.d.). Berkeley Law.

Carroll, K. (2021). Smart Cars are Getting Smarter: Legal Personhood for Self Driving Vehicles . Seton Hall Law Review, 12-25.

Carroll, K. (2021). Smart Cars are Getting Smarter: Legal Personhood for Self Driving Vehicles . Seton Hall Law, 2.

Consumer Protection Act. (2019).

Dalley, P. J. (2011). A Theory of Agency Law. University of Pittsburgh Law Review, 344-350. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5195/lawreview.2011.164

Darsh Parekh, N. P. (2022). A Review on Autonomous Vehicles: Progress, Methods and Challenges. Electronics, 7-9. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/electronics11142162

Elvia Arcelia, Q. A. (2015). Natural Persons, Juridical Persons and Legal Personhood. Mexican Law Review, 101-115. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.mexlaw.2015.12.005

Gaakeer, J. (2016). “Sua cuique persona ?” A Note on the Fiction of Legal Personhood and a Reflection on Interdisciplinary Consequences. Law & Literature, 287–317. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/1535685X.2016.1232920

Indian Contract Act. (1872).

Institute, A. L. (2005, May 17). Agency Defined, Restatement (Third) Of Agency. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.

NHTSA. (2016). nhtsa.gov.

NHTSA. (2022). Levels of Automation.

O'Brien v. Surgical, Inc., No. 10 C 3005 WL 304079 (2011).

Rafferty, J. P. (2017, September 30). The Rise of the Machines : Pros and Cons of the Industrial Revolution.

Singh, S. (2017). Attribution of Legal Personhood to Artificially Intelligent Beings. Bharati Law Review, 197-199.

Solum, L. B. (1992). Legal Personhood for Artificial Intelligences. North Carolina Law Review, 1231-1233.

The Motor Vehicles Act. (1988).

Vladeck, D. C. (2014). Machines without Principals : Liability Rules and Artificial Intelligence. Washington law review, 117-150.

Wang, J. (2021). Towards the Unified Principles for Level 5 Autonomous Vehicles. Engineering, 1316-1324. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eng.2020.10.018

Wrbka, M. F. (2022). AI and Legal Personhood. In C. P. L. A. DiMatteo, The Cambridge Handbook of Artificial Intelligence : Global Perspectives on Law and Ethics (pp. 288-303). Cambridge : Cambridge University Press. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781009072168.028