RESEARCH ON OBTAINING NOODLES FROM NON-BREADABLE FLOURS FOR PEOPLE WITH GLUTEN INTOLERANCEOlga Tabunşcic 1, Svetlana
Fedorciucova 2, Valentina
Calmâș 3, Adrian Bulican 4 1 Department, Trade, Tourism and Catering The, Academy of Economic Studies of Moldova |
|
||
|
|||
Received 20 March 2022 Accepted 01 April 2022 Published 27 April 2022 Corresponding Author Olga Tabunşcic, tabunscic.olga@ase.md DOI 10.29121/IJOEST.v6.i2.2022.313 Funding: This research
received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial,
or not-for-profit sectors. Copyright: © 2022 The
Author(s). This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution,
and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are
credited. |
ABSTRACT |
|
|
In the Republic of Moldova, as in other countries in
the world, there is an increase in the number of people suffering from celiac
disease, one of the most common chronic digestive disorders. This disease is
difficult to diagnose and the only treatment being a strict diet, by avoiding
the consumption of gluten-containing products. This article analyzes the
assortment and sale price of agglutenic products from the Republic of Moldova
and presents new technologies for obtaining noodles from unpacifiable brown
rice flour with acceptable sensory and physico-chemical characteristics and
with a sale price accessible to all social categories of people with gluten
intolerance. The following methods were used to achieve the aims of the
paper: empirical (observation methods based on the collection of information
on types of agglutinative products), experimental methods - for the
elaboration of new technologies for the production of noodles, and
calculation methods - for determining the energy value, indicators
nutritional value and cost of manufactured products. Following this study,
recipes, and the technology for obtaining 4 types of noodles from brown rice
flour without additives and with additives were developed. |
|
||
Keywords: Celiac Disease, Agglutenic Products, Noodles 1. INTRODUCTION
In the Republic of Moldova in recent decades, there has been an
increase in the number of people suffering from celiac disease.
Epidemiological studies show that 15% of the world's population suffers from
celiac disease, with variations depending on the area, more cases being
recorded in Europe and fewer in the USA and Asia. According to the statistics
of the Romanian Association for Gluten Intolerance, in Romania the number of
people following a gluten-free diet, on the recommendation of the doctor, is
estimated at about 1 million people Bureau Veritas Audits Cristim for Gluten
Free Certification (2019). In the Republic of Moldova the first celiac
disease patients were diagnosed in 1998, since then more than 300 children
have been registered suffering from this disease, but some specialists Bukharov
(2020) consider that the real share of people affected by
celiac disease in our country is unknown, due to the wide spectrum of
symptoms, celiac disease is difficult to diagnose, the only treatment being a
strict diet, by avoiding the consumption of gluten-containing products.
Statistics show that the number of people who need to feed only with
agglutenic products, both globally and in the Republic of Moldova is increasing.
People in our country diagnosed with celiac disease face problems, such as:
the limited assortment of local |
|
||
agglutenic food products sold
in the trade network, but also the lack of public catering establishments where to consume agglutenic dishes.
Thus, every sick person is often forced to purchase imported agglutenic
products that are expensive compared to the incomes of the population and to
prepare their own food.
According
to data from BBC World news, in 2015, 70 million Americans excluded gluten from
their diet, in the United Kingdom 7% of adults avoid gluten due to food
allergies or intolerances and 8% of the population does not consume gluten
products out of a desire to have a healthier lifestyle. The director of the
Observatory for Scientific Communication of the Pompeu Fabra University (UPF),
Gonzalo Casino in the publication” La Vanguardia", stated that there is no
scientific reason for a healthy person to eliminate gluten from his diet. The
specialist believes that gluten is a vital nutrient for the health of the body,
as it helps in the fight against cardiovascular diseases and reduces the risk
of certain types of cancer and type 2 diabetes, and the exclusion of gluten
from the diet can cause intestinal damage and the occurrence of constipation
and respiratory problems Are Gluten-Free Products Healthy Or Not (2019).
In the
Republic of Moldova there are no official statistics on the number of patients
with gluten intolerance, due to the lack of a National Register of primary
registered patients, both in public and private medical institutions. The
specialist in pediatric gastroenterology at the Ministry of Health, Ion Mihu,
says that the real share of people affected by celiac disease in the Republic
of Moldova is unknown, as these patients remain underdiagnosed. Taking into
account the multitude of atypical clinical manifestations, they are treated in
terms of another pathology Bukharov
(2020).
2. MATERIALS AND
METHODS
For
the analysis of information on the assortment and price of gluten-free products
sold in grocery stores on the territory of the Republic of Moldova, was used
the observation method, which was based on the collection of information on
types of agglutenic products, by categories of producers, and their price. The
research was conducted between January 2021 and September 2021.
For
the development of new technologies for the production of noodles from unpacifiable
flours with various additions, was used the experimental method.
For
the analysis of organoleptic indicators (appearance, color, consistency, taste,
smell) of varieties of noodles, produced in the laboratory, was applied the
score scale of 0 - 5 points; and the technological characteristics, such as
boiling time, boiling increase, were determined by experimental laboratory
methods.
The
energy value, nutritional value indicators and the cost of the developed
products – were determined by the calculation method.
3. RESULTS AND
DISCUSSIONS
In the
Republic of Moldova there is no organized environment for this category of
patients, there are no food establishments that would have agglutenic dishes in
the assortment offer, the menus in schools and kindergartens also do not
contain agglutenic dishes, so each patient is forced to prepare his own food or
order on-line import products, the quality of which they cannot be sure, but which
cost less than the import ones sold in the stores in the country.
There
are only a few local producers in the milling and bakery field, such as: BioEM
LLC, the primary product of which is sorizul, the brand offers soriz flour and
hemp seeds, both gluten-free; Art-ProEco LLC, the "Ronti" brand,
cereal flakes, among which gluten-free flakes. According to the data provided
by the sources Produse Din Sorg Fara Gluten, (N.D.),List of
Our Gluten-Free Products: Flour, Desserts, and Bread, (2020) the list of Moldovan producers and
stores offering gluten-free products are:
·
Natka
Marvelatka artisan bakery-gluten-free bread.
·
Networks
of Kaufland stores and Nr. 1 propose to the bio shelf gluten-free German bread,
biscuits, and other preparations of this category.
·
Pure
taste-gluten and sugar free desserts and buckwheat bread.
·
George
Standard-online store with bakery products, including gluten-free.
·
Gluten-free
sorghum products.
Even
if in recent years, some producers of agglutenic products have appeared on the
domestic market, their assortment is very limited, mainly being some assortment
of flours, bread, biscuits, and there is no gluten-free pasta, these being only
imported.
According
to the source Bukharov
(2020), in Europe in 2017 there were over 17,000
certified gluten-free products, an increase of 47.5% compared to 2016.
Currently, there is a global concern about celiac disease, both in its medical aspects
and in ensuring adequate nutrition and the supply of agglutenic food products.
Concerns regarding the design and creation of agglutenic flour foods come from
research and not from industries. It is essential that a gluten-free product is
similar to a regular product, in terms of sensory and physico-chemical
characteristics.
The
Republic of Moldova being a country, where growing wheat and producing bread is
a traditional custom, and the traditional pasta are homemade noodles, which are
used in various traditional dishes such as soup
(zeama), white baba, noodles with cheese, noodle pudding and so on. These
noodle dishes are traditionally produced only from wheat flour, which limits
people with gluten intolerance to the consumption of these traditional dishes.
Analyzing
the supply of noodles, sold in grocery stores in Moldova, we find that are
proposed for sale about 7 types of gluten-free pasta made of white and brown
rice, buckwheat, corn, hemp, sorghum, and millet that are imported from Ukraine
from manufacturer Ms. Tally. The Kaufland store produces under the K-free brand
3 types of corn pasta with the addition of 2% chickpea flour (spaghetti, penne,
fusilli). From the Italian manufacturer "Di Nunzio" can be found
three types of agglutinative pasta - beans, lentils, and green peas.
Information on the assortment and price of gluten-free products sold in grocery
stores on the territory of the Republic of Moldova is presented in Table 1. Analyzing the offers of the
commercial networks in the Republic of Moldova, we find that the assortment of
agglutinated pasta is only imported and at an exaggerated price, ranging from
130 lei to 280 lei per kg.
Based
on those mentioned, we intend to develop new recipes and technologies of
agglutenic noodles from unpacifiable flours with various additions. It is known
that dough from unpacifiable flours is difficult to stretch, and to prevent
sticking and deformation, a large amount of flour is required when stretching.
To reduce the cooking time and the consumption of flour used for stretching and
cutting, was used the KINGH off 3113 pasta machines.
For
the development of new recipes and technologies, brown rice flour was subjected
to research 5 samples of dough for noodles were prepared, namely:
·
sample
without additions, prepared of flour without additions.
·
sample
with the addition of flaxseed flour.
·
sample
with the addition of tomato paste.
·
sample
with the addition of chopped spinach.
·
sample
with the addition of chopped beetroot.
Table 1 Assortment and price of agglutenic products sold in stores in the
Republic of Moldova |
|||
Store
name |
Brand |
Product
assortment |
Price(lei/kg) |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
BioEM |
soriz flour |
31 |
|
NaturMD |
semolina of soriz |
48 |
|
It is an online store that deals with the sale and
delivery of natural products without taste enhancers, chemical additives, and
E-s. The first presentation and sales room appear on March 15, 2020. |
groats of soriz |
31 |
|
Aliment Ulei |
flour of sea buckthorn fruits |
420 |
|
flour of armor seeds |
120 |
||
flour of pumpkin seeds |
108 |
||
flaxseed flour |
72 |
||
flour of grape seeds. |
72 |
||
Art- ProEco |
ronți buckwheat flour cereals |
95 |
|
ronți cereal from soriz flour |
90 |
||
ronți pumpkin seed cereals |
95 |
||
ronți cereals of hemp flour |
90 |
||
ronți cereals made from grape flour |
95 |
||
Ms. Taily |
amaranth flour |
176 |
|
sorghum flour |
72 |
||
green buckwheat flour |
72 |
||
chickpea flour |
72 |
||
brown rice flour |
90 |
||
white rice flour |
80 |
||
buckwheat pasta |
260 |
||
rice pasta |
235 |
||
corn pasta |
170 |
||
sorghum pasta |
260 |
||
color pasta |
130 |
||
millet pasta |
280 |
||
hemp pasta |
220 |
||
Conah International |
hemp flour |
460 |
|
BIOMed |
Solaris |
buckwheat flour |
140 |
BIO products store |
chickpea flour |
75 |
|
rice flour |
130 |
||
Probios |
corn flour |
340 |
|
almond flour |
260 |
||
BIO products store |
ViVio |
almond flour |
260 |
AromeBio |
BioPlanet |
tapioca flour |
137 |
a store of BIO products imported from Poland |
almond flour |
1600 |
|
green banana flour |
495 |
||
Bliss |
Di Nunzio |
bean pasta |
276 |
lentil pasta |
276 |
||
green pea pasta |
276 |
||
Source: elaborated by the
authors |
In order to compare the quality indices of
noodles obtained according to new recipes, for each type of sample were
prepared and control samples of wheat flour. The ingredients in the recipes and
their proportions from which the control samples were prepared are presented in
Table 2. The researchers were subjected to
5 samples of dough.
Table 2 Sample
recipe for 100 g of wheat flour dough |
|||||
No. sample |
Name
of the sample |
Flour
(%) |
Eggs
(%) |
Salt
(%) |
Additions
(%) |
1 |
Wheat flour noodles |
56 |
40 |
4 |
- |
2 |
with
the addition of flaxseed flour |
46 |
40 |
4 |
10 |
3 |
with the addition of tomato paste |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
4 |
with
the addition of chopped spinach |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
5 |
with the addition of chopped beets |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
Source: elaborated by the
authors |
The algorithm of the experiments performed in
laboratory conditions is shown in the Figure 1.
|
Figure 1 Algorithm of experiments
conducted in laboratory conditions Source: elaborated by the authors |
For
the research, was used brown rice flour grown in Urcaina, from the manufacturer
Ms. Tailly. In order to establish the optimal ratio between the raw materials
used, several dough samples were prepared. As a result of several attempts, the
optimal recipes for 100 g of dough were developed, which are presented in Table 3.
Table 3 Sample
recipes for 100 g of brown rice flour dough |
|||||
No. sample |
Name
of the sample |
Flour
(%) |
Eggs
(%) |
Salt
(%) |
Additions
(%) |
1 |
Brown rice flour noodles |
56 |
40 |
4 |
- |
2 |
-
flaxseed flour |
51 |
35 |
4 |
10 |
3 |
- tomato paste |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
4 |
-
chopped spinach |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
5 |
- beet puree |
56 |
30 |
4 |
10 |
Source: elaborated by the
authors |
Thus, as presented in Table 3, Table 5 recipes for brown rice flour
noodles were developed. Recipe 1- no additives; recipe 2 - 15% brown rice flour
was replaced with flaxseed flour; for recipes 3,4, and 5 the addition
constituted 10% of the flour mass. The samples were boiled to obtain
soft-boiled noodles, the cooking time being 5 minutes from the time of cooking
for the rice flour noodles and 8 minutes for the wheat flour noodles. To get
the “al dente” consistency, the cooking time is 3 minutes from the time of
cooking for the brown rice flour noodles and 6 minutes for the wheat flour
noodles. It is found that for samples 1 and 2 the boiling water is opalescent,
for samples 3, 4, 5 the water was colored specifically for the raw materials
used. During the boiling of the noodles, they did not deform, and no foam
formed on the surface. The mass increase of brown rice flour noodles compared
to wheat flour noodles is shown in Figure 2.
|
Figure 2 Mass growth of noodles from
brown rice and wheat flour (n times) Source: elaborated by the authors |
Sample 1 (rice noodles without addition) after
boiling was increased by 2 times in volume, and samples with added 2, 3, 4, and
5 were increased by 2.1 times in volume. In comparison with wheat flour
noodles, which after boiling increased the volume by 2.5 and 2.7 times, the
samples obtained from brown rice flour show a smaller increase in volume. The
greatest increase in volume after boiling shows samples with the addition of
tomato paste. After boiling the noodles were squeezed through a sieve and
rinsed with cold boiled water, then the organoleptic indices were analyzed,
which are characterized in Table 4.
Table 4 Characteristic
of the organoleptic indices of brown rice flour noodles |
|||||
No.
sample |
Consistency |
Appearance |
Colour |
Smell |
Taste |
1 |
Soft, elastic. |
Well preserved shape |
Golden yellow |
Specific to wheat flour |
Somewhat salty, with a weak taste of boiled rice. |
2 |
Soft,
when chewed, it tends to agglomerate. |
Agglomerate,
with small brown particles |
Light
brown |
Specific
to flour, no foreign smell |
To
the extent salty, pronounced taste of flax seeds. |
3 |
Soft, sticky. |
Well preserved shape |
Light orange |
Specific to flour, with a faint tomato smell |
Somewhat salty, with a tomato-specific taste |
4 |
Soft,
sticky. |
Well-preserved
shape with small pieces of spinach |
Light
green |
Specific
to flour, with a faint smell of spinach |
To
a certain extent salty with a slightly pronounced spinach taste |
5 |
Soft, sticky. |
Well-preserved shape with small pieces of beetroot |
Light red |
Specific to the flour, weakly pronounced by the beet |
To the extent salty with a pleasant taste of boiled
beets |
Source: elaborated by the
authors |
The
images of the noodles obtained from brown rice flour are shown in the Figure 3:
|
Figure 3 Images of brown rice noodles with various additives
before and after boiling a-rolled dough; b-noodles before boiling; c-noodles
after boiling Source: elaborated
by the authors |
To
assess the indices of organoleptic, the score scale of 0-5 points was used, the
sensory analysis of the resulting samples was evaluated by 5 people, who
analyzed the appearance, consistency, colour, smell and taste of brown rice
noodles. The data obtained are presented in Table 5.
Sample
2, with the addition of flaxseed flour, after organoleptic analysis has
accumulated an unsatisfactory score of 2.84 points, because after boiling it presented
an inappropriate appearance, an uneven color and during mastectomy shows a
tendency to agglomerate, this sample is not accepted for consumption.
Table 5 Sensory
analysis by score scale of brown rice flour samples |
||||||
No. sample |
Average number of points awarded |
Total score |
||||
Appearance and shape |
Consistency |
Colour |
Smell |
Taste |
||
1 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
5 |
2 |
2,6 |
1,6 |
2 |
3 |
3 |
2,84 |
3 |
4,6 |
4 |
5 |
5 |
4,8 |
4,68 |
4 |
5 |
4 |
4 |
4,6 |
5 |
4,52 |
5 |
5 |
4 |
4,4 |
5 |
4,6 |
4,6 |
Source: elaborated by the authors |
Samples
1, 3, 4 and 5 have accumulated a satisfactory score and can be accepted for
consumption. After the sensor analysis, the energy value of rice flour noodles
was calculated as shown in Figure 4.
|
Figure 4 Energy value of rice and wheat
flour noodles (kcal / 100g) Source: elaborated by the authors |
Compared
to wheat flour noodles the energy value of rice flour noodles is higher by 4%
and the nutritional value index is lower by 10%, for the reason that rice flour
contains a higher amount of lipids and carbohydrates and a lower amount of
minerals and vitamins. The nutritional value indices of the noodles are shown
in Figure 5. According to the obtained data it
is observed that the additions of raw materials contributed to a decrease in
the energy value, for the reason that a smaller amount of egg was used in the
reception of these samples.
|
Figure 5 Nutritional value indices of
rice and wheat flour noodles Source: elaborated by the authors |
According to the data obtained, it can be
observed that the addition of spinach and chopped beets for rice and wheat
flour noodles contributes to a decrease in energy value by 5% and an increase
in nutritional value by 11% (for spinach addition) and by 0.7% (for beet
addition), and the addition of tomato paste contributes to a decrease in
nutritional value by 11%, for the reason that compared to beets, spinach
contains a lower amount of vitamins, such as A and C. The price calculated for
1 kg of rice and wheat flour noodles is shown in the Figure 6.
|
Figure 6 Price of rice and wheat flour noodles (lei / kg) Source: elaborated by the authors |
From the above, we conclude that rice noodles
compared to wheat flour noodles have the following:
·
a
change in mass less by 20% and a boiling time less by 60%.
·
the
energy value is higher by 5%, and the nutritional value is lower by 10.
·
the
addition of flaxseed flour forms an agglomerated appearance and an uneven
color.
·
the
price for 1 kg of noodles is more than 4 times.
For
consumption, noodles made from brown rice flour without addition and noodles
with the addition of tomato paste, chopped spinach and chopped beets were
accepted.
4. CONCLUSIONS
The
agglutenic products market on the territory of the Republic Of Moldova is
characterized mostly only by import products (from Ukraine, Poland, Italy, and
Romania) with an assortment of agglutenic pastes (from hemp, rice, chickpeas,
peas, beans, soriz, corn, buckwheat, lentils, pumpkin seeds) and with an
assortment of about 20 types of agglutenic flours.
In the
Republic of Moldova are sold local agglutenic flours with the brand Lacrima de
Aur (of sea buckthorn fruits, armor seeds, pumpkin seeds, flax seeds, and of
grape seeds).
As a
result of the research, recipes were elaborated and the technology of obtaining
noodles from brown rice flour without additions and with additions was
developed. Thus, the research resulted in 4 samples of brown rice flour that
are accepted for consumption and production:
·
Sample
1 (Brown rice flour noodles)
·
Sample
3 (Brown rice flour noodles with the addition of tomato paste)
·
Sample
4 (Brown rice flour noodles with the addition of chopped spinach)
·
Sample
5 (Noodles from brown rice flour with the addition of beets.
Sample
2 (brown rice noodles with added flaxseed flour) did not meet the quality
indices and was not accepted for consumption.
Compared to wheat flour noodles, brown rice noodles have the following characteristics: boiling time with 60% lower (5 minutes), volume after boiling with 20% lower, energy value with 4% lower (259 kcal/100 g), nutritional value indices with 10% lower (VN10=7, 21) and cost price 4 times higher (54.03 lei/kg). The addition of spinach contributes to an increase in nutritional value by 11% and the addition of tomato paste to a decrease in nutritional value by 11% and the addition of beets contributes to an increase in nutritional value by 0.7%.
REFERENCES
Are Gluten-Free Products Healthy or Not (2019). Www.Dozadesanatate.Ro/Produsele-Fara-Gluten-Sunt-Sanatoase-Sau-Nu/
Bukharov, B. (2020). I Pay Them A Disability Pension And They Wash Their Hands of It. People With Celiac Disease Complain That The Moldovan Authorities Are Doing Nothing To Make Their Lives Easier, Www.E-Sanatate.Md/News/2173/Le-Platesc-Pensie-Pentru-Invaliditate-Si-Cu-Asta-S-Au-Spalat-Pe-Maini-Bolnavii-De-Celiachie-Se-Plang-ça-Autoritatile-Din-Moldova-Nu-Fac-Nimic-Pentru-A-Le-Usura-Viata
Bureau Veritas Audits Cristim For Gluten Free Certification (2019). Www.Bureauveritas.Ro/Newsroom/Bureau-Veritas-Auditeaza-Cristim-Pentru-Certificarea-Gluten-Free
Duta, D., And Belc, N. (2019). Special Products For Food Intolerances, Www.Academia.Edu/20261203/Produse_Speciale_Pentru_Intolerante_Alimentare
List of Our Gluten-Free Products : Flour, Desserts And Bread, (2020). Https://Ea.Md/Lista-Producatorilor-De-La-Noi-Care-Au-Produse-Fara-Gluten-Faina-Deserturi-Si-Paine/
Produse Din Sorg Fara Gluten, (N.D.). Https://Www.Facebook.Com/Faraglutenfabricatinmoldova/?Ref=Gs&Eid=Arbeeawaugjv7hjm2hy6bxnezyg3_Pm0borlghgcxqrtjpmv1reakoehzxkddrxr0yz4e1l7fwk8-Yek&Fref=Gs&Dti=2026571547488514&Hc_Location=Group
This work is licensed under a: Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License
© Granthaalayah 2014-2022. All Rights Reserved.