ANALYZING WHAT PERMANENT ACADEMIC CLASSROOM ACTIVITY OF ENGLISH TEACHERS TELL US ABOUT THEIR PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT NEEDS: PRIMARY SCHOOLS IN FOCUS

How to cite this article (APA): Kisi, M. T., Kitila, T., and Zewdie, M. (2022). Analyzing What Permanent Academic Classroom Activity of English Teachers Tell Us About Their Professional Development Needs: Primary Schools in Focus. International Journal of Engineering Technologies and Management Research, 9(2), 93–109. doi: 10.29121/ijetmr.v9.i2.2022.1057 93 ANALYZING WHAT PERMANENT ACADEMIC CLASSROOM ACTIVITY OF ENGLISH TEACHERS TELL US ABOUT THEIR PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT NEEDS: PRIMARY SCHOOLS IN FOCUS


INTRODUCTION
Continuous Professional Development (CPD) is the concept and practice of ongoing structured lifelong learning of professionals in the teachers' development needs Minae and David (2017). their finding indicates that CPD is a necessity for teachers to fully engage with their development. They state that English teachers choose professional development activities relevant to their development need for development so that they discover new opportunities, develop their linguistic knowledge and the pedagogic skills. According to them, when English their professional development needs are considered, they would increase their overall understanding of the target language in genuine interactive situations. Because professionally developed teachers can apply classroom teaching practices to help students understand 94 and use English language appropriately Minae and David (2017). This means with increasing English proficiency; teachers also tend to use language teaching strategies that allow them to facilitate language use and interact more effectively with their colleagues and students.
Assessing and identifying professional development (PD) needs of primary English language teachers have never received significant interest at the global level Zein (2015). However, plenty of studies have explored the role of teachers in the classroom Richards (2006). Previous studies have focused on identifying pedagogical concerns, like assessing learning outcomes (Wang, 2002), implementation of communicative language teaching to develop teachers' profession Butler (2015), Desta et al. (2013), school based CPD in Addis Ababa; Clark (2018), key challenges and pedagogic implication; incorporating corrective feedback Zhao (2009), the kinds of challenges that teachers encounter in their classrooms Cheng (2010), effective professional development strategies of English language teachers by Hismanoglua (2010). This means there has been little, or no research conducted on what the actual teaching practices report about teachers' professional development needs. This has motivated the study.
In Ethiopian few studies were conducted on teacher professional development. For example, Fekede and Pavi (2015) study professional learning of teachers in Ethiopia. His major study focused on the challenges and implications of reforms in education. Although Fekede and Pavi explore potential and actual barriers that hinder TPD in Ethiopian schools, the study entirely reports about professional learning. Similarly, Workneh and Tassew (2013) explored teacher training and professional development in Ethiopia. In their findings, they pointed out that education quality can be improved by developing teachers' skills, attitudes, and work conditions. From this study, one can understand that teachers' development is one of the key factors in delivering quality education. The implication of this is teachers seek development in the areas of the profession.
Similarly, a study on teacher induction and the CPD in Ethiopia by Tadele (2013) shows teachers need professional development program to enhance their classroom practices. Supporting this finding, Desta et al. (2013) point out that school based CPD is used to enhance teachers' knowledge of the subject and skills in teaching. In their study, they focused on the importance of school based CPD in general. Similarly, Rukya (2016) reveals that a study on female teachers' professional development was not conducted. She recommends that action research is helpful method to develop teachers' knowledge. This means that the studies conducted so far have not considered what teachers actually do in the class. What teachers' classroom teaching practices tell us about the teacher's professional development needs has not yet been explored. This study was motivated to fill the gap in this regard.
In order to help us understand potential problems in English teacher development is vital to explore the overall trends and practices of the English teachers in primary schools. Despite the fact that numerous studies have investigated the various aspects professional development of teachers, a plethora of research on teachers' professional development needs has not yet been done. Little or no empirical research has devoted to study need-based professional development of teachers. This means that many of the studies so far have not focused on exploring teachers' professional development needs. The present study was motivated to explore what teachers' classroom practices talk about the teachers' language use and skills in teaching.

95
Studies conducted outside of Ethiopia, for example, Eba (2013) and Desta et al. (2013) discuss school based professional development activities are not effective due to various reasons; for example, they ignore needs and expectations of teachers. Their findings further reveal that lack of professional development opportunities to practice is also another challenge. Naom (2013) reports that most professional development of teacher of today is ineffective due to its inabilities not only to bring changes in teacher practice in classroom but also to improve student learning in class. In connection with this, Eba (2013) states that teachers CPD programs were not designed to match with what the teachers are required to have in order to teach upper primary school levels. Eba elaborates that teachers' classroom performance do not have confidence in a wide range of English language and academic levels found in the classroom. This study was planned to fill this gap.
In their study about English language instructors' professional development needs, Eksi and Cape (2012) states that primary school teachers lack content knowledge and pedagogic skills that respond to their professional development need. Their finding reveals that teachers' lack of content knowledge and the pedagogic skills. This means the teachers are ineffective. Similarly, most of the studies in Ethiopia, for example, Clark (2018) reports that the contents of the schoolbased CPD were not designed to fit professional development needs of all teachers. This means the contents of the lessons were not designed according to the professional development need of the teachers.
Their study further shows the contents of English language improvement program (ELIP) and school based CPD activities are not fully relevant to the teachers' professional development needs. They further explained that there has been inappropriate balance between the national educational reform and individual teacher's professional development needs. Abraham (2018) holds a similar opinion in stating that CPD activities were not sufficient enough to equip teachers with the professional support they sought. Eba (2013) also points out that English teacher's poor competence and proficiency in the English have to be a priority concern. He recommends the need to explore professional development what English language teachers in primary school do in the classes. This means, so far, no literature has explored what permanent classroom activities like in the classes. Partly, the present study is part of the attempt to fill this gap.
Reports from different government offices reveal that the performance of the schools so far regarding CPD is not satisfactory (Haromaya University, 2007, (MOE) (2013), (MOE) (2014). The CPD programs in the schools are not achieving the desired objectives by improving student achievement. Dereje (2015) holds a similar opinion when he reports that the CPD practices at school do not have the basic features of successful teacher professional development. His finding also shows the CPD program is not strongly linked and engaging the teachers. That means the CPD activities designed do not address the teacher's classroom situations. Not addressing teacher professional development needs to enhance classroom activities may result into a mismatch between teachers' teaching goals and the students' leaning needs.
Future Search Conference's (2012) held at Ambo University reveals that there are direct relationships between teacher professional development and students' academic engagement. The report, however, did not discuss anything related to what English teachers needed to develop professionally. That means main focus of the report was not need based professional development of teachers. Similarly, Zein (2016) indicates that what teachers actually do in the class and their quality of language use has not received significant attention. Inadequate English language Analyzing What Permanent Academic Classroom Activity of English Teachers Tell Us About Their Professional Development Needs: Primary Schools in Focus International Journal of Research -GRANTHAALAYAH 96 proficiency in the classroom was observed here and there in Ethiopia. This can be due to that fact that quality education has been deteriorating and students' achievement is declining Fekede and Fiorucci (2012), Lemlem (2010) and Tessema (2006).
To this end, strategies and programs were needed to develop teachers through continuous professional development so that teachers develop their linguistic knowledge and the pedagogic skills. Other programs in the package that were also introduced to enhance teacher development program include 'English Language Improvement Program (MOE) (2010), National Education Assessments (NEAs), Education Sector Development Programs (ESDP) I and II (2000, 2004 and 2007) respectively. The programs focus on providing in-service training for teachers in the primary and secondary schools for a relatively short period of time. The training emphasizes on improving teacher quality and increase teachers' classroom performances (MOE) (2005). Despite these efforts, however, many English language teachers do not speak English at an operational level. Apparently, teachers' poor language skills and their lack of access to appropriate professional development needs have made it difficult for them to create an effective learning environment for their students.
To creating an effective learning environment for the students, Ministry of Education in Ethiopia (MoE) established English Language Improvement Program (ELIP) in 2003. The ELIP focused on creating interactive, engaging in learning practical and relevant courses for teachers to help them meet their Continuous Professional Development (CPD) needs. However, it has not yet achieved the desired result (MoE, 2007). That means although the program was designed to develop teachers' knowledge and skills in teaching to a new level, the development of teachers has not been successful as desired.
The Profile of primary school English language teachers in Ethiopia tends to show that mainly, students who were not able to join university would join teacher education. Worse still, the pre-service training given to them does not enable them to be proficient enough to teach English. The training does not equip the teachers with the linguistic knowledge and the pedagogic skills they are required to have to teach English in primary schools. Observations and informal discussions with the teachers also show that they have poor command of English. This means they do not have the needed knowledge of the subject they are teaching, and pedagogic skills required to teach English. This inadequate background makes it necessary for the teachers to be given opportunities for CPD that address their needs for development. Indeed, MOE's introductions of different reforms and CPDs in the past for various years have given a long way to address the problems. However, it leaves much to be done yet to improve the situation.
Informal communication and observations the researcher had with primary school English language teachers indicates that the teachers find it difficult to do lessons well in the textbook in use (Grades 5-8). That means they lack linguistic knowledge and the pedagogic skills they are required to have in order to teach English in primary students. Available evidence also shows that several students complete primary school with significantly limited English language use skill. The students also complete secondary school and join university without much improvement in their English language use. This happens in spite of their use of the English language as a medium of instruction in the secondary school and university. This observation has given rise to the need to study the classroom practices of primary school English teachers.

OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY
The objective of the study was to analyse what permanent academic classroom activities of English language in primary schools tell us about their professional development needs.

THE RESEARCH QUESTION
The study was conducted to address the following research questions.
What do permanent classroom activities tell us about teachers' professional development need areas?

THE PARTICIPANTS OF THE STUDY
The study involved English language teachers in primary schools of the selected study area. The study was conducted at North Showa Zone of Oromia regional State in Ethiopia. All the study participants were informed about the objective of the study and the data collection processes began after agreement with all of them.

THE DATA COLLECTION
In this study, the primary purpose of conducting classroom observation was to address the basic question that the study addresses. This means the classroom observation was conducted to gather data about what the English language teachers did well and could not do well enough on permanent academic classroom activities that involve the use of English language in the classes. The permanent academic classroom activities include teacher lesson beginning, lesson running, lesson ending, classroom interaction, and classroom management. The intention was not to criticize the teachers' classroom practices, but to identify gaps where further professional development is needed to develop the English language teachers in primary schools.
To identify the gaps, the lessons were carefully observed from the beginning to the end of the periods and the units for each category were noted down. The classroom observations were conducted for 30 minutes long. In order to conduct classroom observation, four English teachers (two grades 5 and two grade 7) were selected. This means twelve classroom observations were conducted to collect data for this study. Codes were given to the teachers whose classes were observed. For example, T1, T2, T3, and T4 codes were given to the teachers whose classes were observed. The observation was held for 30 minutes. To get appropriate data on the teachers' classroom practices, the four English language teachers were observed four times at different period of time in the 2020/2021 academic year.

ANALYSIS OF CLASSROOM OBSERVATION DATA
The analysis of the data collected was analyzed qualitatively. Themes emerged during classroom observation data were coded initially first and then developed into focused codes. The data obtained from the four (T1, T2, T3 and T4) teachers of English which were observed three times were then developed into focused themes. Then the focused themes supported by theories regarding the focused themes were developed into theory.
The data were collected to obtain relevant data during teacher lesson opening, running, ending, and giving instruction. The data obtained were sampled as follows. T3: Make a group in three. Then tell each other the main points of the yesterday's lesson. (Gave some time to the students to think the answers).
T4: Take the note. All of you copy it to your exercise book.
Let us see the extract from the three teachers again: OT1, OT2, OT3 were observed as follows. T4: Take the note. All of you copy them to your exercise book. The lesson is 13: Revision Exercise. Today, we start Unit 10: The topic is 'who is your nephew": Listening and Speaking: Study Picture. Open your book at page 131.
So far, the classroom observation data obtained related to what teacher classroom activities tell us about their professional development needs have been reported. In the next section, themes that have evolved from the responses of the study participants would be brought together and analyzed. The analysis would give us what the teacher classroom activities tell us about their professional development needs.

ANALYSIS OF PERMANENT CLASSROOM ACTIVITIES
This section presents permanent academic classroom activities of the English language teachers. These activities include teacher lesson opening, running, and ending. Besides, this section discusses other activities the teachers use to deliver the lessons.

TEACHER LESSON OPENING
The English language teachers were observed with while their English language proficiency was weak. Their communication skills in English language were observed poor. This means their English language skills were not good enough to help students achieve the desired lesson objectives. The data showed that the teachers' lesson opening strategies were poor. They did not use quality language to open their lessons well. This means the teachers needed the linguistic potential and the pedagogic skills needed to achieve the desired lesson objectives.
The classroom observation data show that the teachers' lesson opening strategies were poor. This poor quality of the English teachers' language use may be because they lacked the linguistic potential needed to deliver lessons well, or the ways they were trained during their college time affected them or they did not know the importance of lesson opening, or they did not know the strategies they could use to open the lessons well. These ways of opening lessons do not encourage the learners to get motivated towards the lessons. The data showed that the teachers did not apply what (Richards & Lockhart, 1994) called lesson opening strategies. This finding is consistent with Watson (1997). Watson holds a similar opinion when he also states that the strategies of lesson opening are used to motivate students to use their background knowledge. They strategies as Watson reports are that the teacher opened the lessons did not achieve the designed objectives. Scrivener (2012) points out that the opening or beginning of the lesson plays a significant role in the lesson. It seems to be the moment that the teacher can decide whether the learners would be engaged in the lesson or not. Scrivener claims that if something goes wrong at this stage, it can affect the rest of the lesson. This implies that it is important to attract students and cultivate their desire for learning at the beginning of the teaching. Lindsay (2006) discusses that in the opening of the lesson, the teachers should explain to the learners about the aims of the lesson, and how the lesson links to previous ones and what activities they are going to do. Similarly, a lesson opening is the first phase of a lesson structure. Clark (2018) states that lesson opening takes the first 3-5 minutes of the lesson when teachers start to interact with students, and it is the commencement of the first major activity. Teacher lesson opening plays a significant role in the lesson as it could determine whether learning would occur. In contrast, previewing aims at preparing the students for the new lesson by raising their expectation of what will happen (Richard & Thomas, 2005).

THE NATURE OF THE TEACHERS' LESSON RUNNING
T1 and T2 were observed while they were teaching '-ing form of Verbs' but the T3 was observed while teaching word formation. T4's class was observed while teaching reading passage. The passage was Gebeta. They asked the students to tell the class about words containing -ing. It was observed that the students were actively participating in telling the teachers verbs containing -ing. The teachers The data reveal that the observed teachers called their students with their names to answer the questions. Although the teachers nominated one or two students, almost the students handed up to get the chances to answer. This reveals that students' participation was high. The implication is the teachers did well enough in the observed classes. This shows that the teachers already know the importance of calling students in their names when they ask questions. Brown (2001) points out calling students in their names fosters a more interpersonal relationship, removes language barriers, and puts students in a better position to take charge of their learning and feel more confident to question their teachers.
Similarly, Willemsen (1995) states many successful educators agree that learning students' names is fundamental to developing a sense of community in the classroom. Willemsen further points out that a teacher that does not take the time to learn their students' names is often perceived as disinterested and unapproachable. This means by calling on a student by name, it gives the impression that the teacher cares about their success and develops a sense of trust. This also has an effect on student interactions. A study by Syverud (1993) points out that knowing the names of students promotes interaction. Syverud also states that when the professor engages the student in personal conversation, recognizes the students by names, and seems to include them in the domain of attention, the subject matter seems more accessible. The teacher would do more if he or she is provided skills training in teaching.
Let's us look at the following extract again: T1 and T2: who will tell me a word that have -ing. Tell me. Who? T3: Who will tell me words containing -ing? Habatamu and Ayele?
Although T1, T2 and T3 had very good student participation, the observation data reveal they did not do well enough on grammar usages when they asked the questions. They lack the grammar knowledge needed to use appropriate subjectverb agreement. This means the teachers do have problem of applying Subject-Verb-Agreement. The teachers' use of singular subject (a word) with the plural verb (have) shows the teachers have grammar problems. Had the teachers used "Tell me words that have -ing" or "Tell me a word that has -ing", they would have been correct.
Similarly, the teachers' use of will was also inappropriate. The teachers used the simple future tense to talk about the activities going now. This shows that the English language whose classes were observed had difficulties with the use of tenses. Had the teachers got professional development programs that address their development need on language use, they would have performed well enough in the classroom.
The data reveal that the teachers seek appropriate grammar when they teach, instruct, the teachers are required to develop professionally on grammar lessons.
Had the teachers used "…word that has…or …words that have, it could have been better. The implication of this means that the teachers are required to get further development courses on subject-verb agreement. Offering the teachers with further training courses on grammar lessons would equip the teachers with the knowledge they needed to teach English.
The observation data also reveal that the teachers wrote words containing -ing on the blackboard and instructed students to copy the words from the board. Here is an extract from of the teachers' lesson running. The data show that T1 and T2 asked the students the questions. But they become askers and answerers of the question. The students could have done by themselves to find the answers which the teachers required them to solve. This seems the teachers poorly performed the lesson. This might be due to teachers' lack of the knowledge or pedagogic skills they are required to apply to enhance classroom activities. Similarly, it implies that the teachers played dominant roles in the English classes. Further professional development training courses on students centered method of teaching English language would equip the teachers with knowledge and the skills they are required to apply in the classes.
After the class, T1 and T2, T4 were asked to reflect on why they did not allow students to try out the -ing form of the words they were given. The teachers reflected that if they were given this opportunity, the students would disturb by shouting loudly. From the teachers' reflections, one can observe that the students' lack of discipline and attention during the lesson are some of the challenges that had worried the teacher. My observation data of the classes reveal that no noticeable disruption in the progress of the lesson occurred when the teachers form the -ing form of the words themselves. This implies that the T1, T2 and T3 did not do well enough in allowing the students to discuss the question and to find the answers by themselves. Therefore, continuous professional development courses on active learning strategies of teaching English will equip the teachers with the required pedagogic skills.
In T3's and T4's lesson, the introduction included explicit framing of the lesson objectives. Here is an extract from the lesson opening: There was no defined closure. Lesson opening and running strategies were clear that some planned lesson activities had not been completed. The transitions were smooth. There was some variety of lesson activities, with the teacher telling stories to engage pupils with core concepts, asking them to write based on the instructions given. First, T4 made the students write sentences from the instructions given. Then he wanted the student to work in small groups to discuss the sentences. Fink (2005) discusses a teacher can ask a student to help them summarize, write down the main points on a piece of paper what they think are the main points of the lessons. The teachers can review the students' answers to gauge their understanding of the topic.
In T4 and T3's lesson, the lesson running was extracted as follows: The activities want the students to discuss the following sentences with their partners first and then the students are required to copy them into their exercise books. Let us see the extract.
Copy the following into your exercise book.

Dibaba is smaller than Mezgebu.
Then the teacher wanted the students to compare the things in their class using "Than". Here is how the teacher gave the students examples. Here is the extract. T4 and T3: Write 5 sentences using than to compare things in your class.
Example: A ruler is longer than a pencil. Who can write 5 sentences?
The observed data reveal that the observed teachers spent much of their time on Lesson Seven: Comparatives. From this extract, one can understand that there were no clear introductory and closure parts of the lesson. In fact, the teachers asked what the students learnt the day before to activate their prior knowledge as a lesson introduction. Questions can be asked to activate students' prior knowledge. But the teachers are expected to give students sometime to think about the answers. This finding is similar with Fink (2005) who states a teacher can gather background information from the students to shape introductory questions and learning activities to familiarize students with the topics of the lessons.
Transition from lesson introduction to lesson presentations was quick as it was not marked clearly and relatively smooth. Activities largely involved the teacher and questions to the whole class. There was no checking students' understanding of the lessons. The students were asked collectively. What was observed from the observed teachers was stated against what Fink (2005) reveals. Fink states that a teacher need to develop a creative introduction to the topic to stimulate interest and encourage thinking. You can use a variety of approaches to engage students. The data reveal that the teacher lacks this skill to do so. This might imply that the teacher is required further training courses in order to introduce, run and end the lessons. Besides, further professional development courses are needed to the teacher to develop pedagogic skills.
The data from the extract reveal that the observed teachers like other teachers began the lesson by questions. The questions were used to reminder of what the student wanted to do and how they want to do it. The teacher did not praise the students and posed the questions to the whole class. Fink (2005) offering praise for students' work and efforts so that students can begin to view their own intelligence as something that can be developed. A study by Fink (2005) reveals that a teacher has to prepare several different ways of explaining the material (real-life examples, analogies, visuals, etc.) to catch attention of students and appeal to different learning styles. Furthermore, the data show that the teachers appreciated the students who tried to answer the lesson opening questions saying, "Very Good", "Excellent" and "Good". Fink expresses that teacher praise is one of tools that can be a powerful motivator for the students during opening lessons. Research suggests that praise is used in both general and special education classroom in every stage of the lessons. These guides offer recommendation to instructors using praise to maximize its positive impact.
From the observation data, one can also understand that transitions were not well organized. Due to lack of clarity of starting new lessons, the teacher got limited students' response. The lesson task involved varied teaching approach (direct instruction at the beginning and end). Much of the lesson time involved students working in groups. Although there was little evidence of checking students' understanding, students' learning needs, achieving the lesson objectives. Fink (2005) states a teacher has to design and identify strategies to check students' understanding. Checking students understanding of the lessons helps the teachers to design learning activities. Brown (2001) hold a similar opinion that teachers can begin to establish a positive learning environment by showing their passion for the subject matter, using student names, reinforcing student participation during class, and being T2 was observed while teaching '-ing form of Verbs'. The teachers used nearly similar kind of lesson presentation. They asked the students to tell the class about words containing -ing. It was observed that the students were actively participating in telling the teachers verbs containing -ing. The teachers wrote students answers which are verbs containing -ing. The teachers used different kinds of questioning techniques to ask the students. T2 used the same kind of question to ask the students. The extract from T2 was taken as follows.
T2: Tell me word that have -ing. Tell me. Tell me. Who?
The data reveal that all the observed teachers called their students who they wanted to answer the question. Although the three observed teachers differ in asking the number of who would answer the questions, all the students handed up to answer the teachers' questions. This reveals that students' participation was high. The implication is the teachers did well enough in the observed classes. This shows that the teachers already know the importance of calling students in their names when they ask questions. Asking students in their names fosters a more interpersonal relationship, removes language barriers, and puts students in a better position to take charge of their learning and feel more confident to question their teachers. Willemsen (1995) states many successful educators agree that learning students' names is fundamental to developing a sense of community in the classroom. Willemsen further points out that a teacher that doesn't take the time to learn their students' names is often perceived as disinterested and unapproachable. This means by calling on a student by name, it gives the impression that the teacher cares about their success and develops a sense of trust. This also has an effect on student interactions. Syverud (1993) holds a similar opinion in stating that knowing the names of peers by either activity in which they learn each other's names or by hearing the teacher address them promotes interaction between students. Syverud also states that when the professor engages the student in personal conversation, recognizes the students by names, and seems to include them in the domain of attention, the subject matter seems more accessible.
The data from the observed teachers reveal that T2 did not do well enough on grammar usages when they asked the questions. The teacher lacked the knowledge needed to use appropriate subject-verb agreement. Had the teachers used "…word that has…or …words that have, it could have been better. This means the teachers are required to get further development courses on subject-verb agreement. Offering the teachers with further training courses on grammar lessons would equip the teachers with the knowledge they needed to teach English.
The observation data show that the teachers do have problem of applying Subject-Verb-Agreement. The teachers' use of singular subject with the plural verb shows the teachers have grammar problems. Had the teachers used "Tell me words that have -ing" or "Tell me a word that has -ing", they would have been correct. To use appropriate grammar when they teach, instruct, the teachers are required to develop professionally on grammar lessons. The observation data also reveal that the observed teachers wrote words containing -ing on the blackboard and instructed students to copy the words from the board. Here is an extract from of the teachers' lesson running. T1 and T2: Tell me the -ing form of read, study, come and go" Almaz, can you answer the -ing form of read? S1: Reading. The data show that T1 and T2 asked the students the question. But they become askers and answerers of the question. The students could have done by themselves to find the answers which the teachers required the students to solve. This seems the teachers poorly performed the lesson. This might be due to teachers' lack of the knowledge or pedagogic skills they are required to apply to enhance classroom activities. This might imply that the teachers play a dominant role in the English classes they were teaching. Further professional development training courses on students centered method of teaching English language would equip the teachers with knowledge and the skills they are required to apply in the classes.
After the class, T1 and T2 were asked to reflect on why they did not allow students to try to the -ing form of the words the students were given. The teachers reflected that if they were given this opportunity, the students would disturb by shouting loudly. From the teachers' reflections, one can observe that the students' lack of discipline and attention during the lesson are some of the challenges that had worried the teacher. My observation data of the classes reveal that no noticeable disruption in the progress of the lesson occurred when the teachers form the -ing form of the words themselves. This implies that the T1 and T2 did not do well enough in allowing the students to discuss the question and to find the answers by themselves. Therefore, continuous professional development courses on active learning strategies of teaching English will equip the teachers with the required pedagogic skills to apply new knowledge so that the teachers build their skills set and knowledge about lesson running

THE NATURE OF THE TEACHERS' LESSON ENDING
The lesson ending by T1, T2 and T3, T4 was extracted below. T1, T2 and T3, T4: open your book on page-----. And copy activities One and Two into your exercise books and do the activities for tomorrow.
The observation data from the extract reveal that the teachers tried to tell the students what they are going to do for the next classes. They tried to inform the students as they should copy the activities into their exercise books and do the answers to the activities as they are instructed in the student textbook. The classroom observation data exposed that the observed teachers did not try to give the students a general summary of the lesson of the day. Besides, it seems to me that the teachers did not check whether the students have understood the main points of the lesson of the day or not. Not doing so means that the teachers did not recap the main points of the lesson of the day. This means the teacher could not do well enough in the end the lesson ending. This implies that the teachers are required to get CPD opportunities on the lessons would be brought to an end.
In order to check students understanding of the lesson, the teacher asked the whole class weather they had questions. Most students raised hands to volunteer Analyzing What Permanent Academic Classroom Activity of English Teachers Tell Us About Their Professional Development Needs: Primary Schools in Focus International Journal of Research -GRANTHAALAYAH 106 answers and many of them answered simultaneously. The students seemed almost engage with tasks. Students' eagerness to answer the question reveals that there was a high degree of individual involvement. Fink (2005) states that the best way to end a lesson is to give students some kind of review activity so that they may see the progress the students have made in just one lesson. One of the most common and easiest to implement is simply taking the last 5 minutes of class to ask your students, "What have you learned today?" What the classroom observation data tell us about the teachers' professional development needs are summarized as follows.

Figure 1 Teacher professional development needs areas
The implication of this is the teachers are required their skill set and stay up to date on school trends, increase their own teaching performances and adding to the school value. The response exposed both young and experienced English language teachers to new ideas, solidify the knowledge and increase their experts on how the lessons run. To put it in nutshell, opportunities like workshops, conferences and other networking events allow English language teachers to branch out to meet learning needs. This means new skills acquired through professional development training can be critical to opening new doors within the field.