ShodhKosh: Journal of Visual and Performing ArtsISSN (Online): 2582-7472
DEVELOPMENT OF A SUSTAINABLE BUSINESS MODEL FOR DENIM Udita Shree 1 1 Master
Scholar, Fashion Design, Department of Art & Design, Sharda University,
Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh 201310, India 2 Professor,
Department of Art & Design, Sharda University, Greater Noida, Uttar Pradesh
201310, India
1. INTRODUCTION Given the huge demand for denim in the apparel industry,
the denim revolution is worth exploring. By definition, denim
is a woven fabric made entirely of cotton yarn. One of its key characteristics
is the amount and variety of extra-structural effects that can be induced on
denim. Hamja (2013) A strong cotton twill fabric called denim has a weft that
passes under two or more warp threads (hence the name "double"). This
twill weave creates the familiar diagonal ribbing of the fabric. It has a gray weft and a coloured warp. Most denim is made using a
left-handed or right-handed twill in a 2/1 or 3/1 pattern. Arjun
et al. (n.d.) Probably the most interesting feature of denim is its irregularity. While fabric manufacturers work hard to ensure their products are free of structural and design flaws, denim is designed to feel a bit rebellious and modern. Hamja (2013) Another important factor behind the popularity of denim is its utility. Although it originated with cowboys who used knitted denim as workwear, today denim is widely used. A technique called denim washing is used to soften the
material and give it a worn look. It is done to stabilize the product's
dimensions due to fabric shrinkage and create effects such as colour fading,
wrinkling, seam puckering, hairiness, pilling, softened hand feel, etc. Since
denim makes up most of the laundry that is washed, the word "wash"
started to refer to the manufacturing process of denim clothing. Csanák (n.d.-b) Washing denim Dry is a key part of washing denim. Daily dry procedures are quite common when washing denim. Before the wet process, the dry denim process uses mechanical abrasion to change the visual appearance of the fabric without affecting its structure or properties. Islam & Hassan (2021) Denim is undoubtedly one of the flexible textiles for all seasons, however, this material also has a disadvantage in terms of environmental impact. It is believed that one of the worst ecological and ethical footprints (impact on the human environment, business, activity, etc.) in the fashion business is left by the denim sector. According to a Greenpeace report, 1.7 million tons of synthetic compounds are needed to create two billion pairs of jeans consistently, and water usage in production can reach up to 7,000 litres per set. Jiby (2017) Despite the environmental reality, denim continues to be a thriving segment of the fashion sector. It is important to remember that one of the most environmentally damaging technologies is washing denim. In 2010, the facts were considered. Csanák (n.d.-b) Therefore, it is crucial that denim businesses take responsibility for their actions, engage in innovation, and promotes sustainability to prevent environmental abuse later in the supply chain. Additionally, the denim industry is among the worst when it comes to promoting consumerism (selfish and pointless accumulation of goods or economic idealism). They are increasingly driven by a classical market economy system that lays the foundations for a throwaway society based on economies of scale, planned product obsolescence, short product life cycles, and subsequently ever-increasing consumer demand for new goods. and services. De Brito (2008) Although the technologies commonly used now are more environmentally friendly when combined with modern, less polluting chemicals and suitable wastewater treatment facilities, disadvantages such as high energy and water consumption, multi-stage production process, and great efforts by denim industry professionals to promote waste management in developing new, more ecological ones. Csanák (n.d.-b) Due to the vast amount of chemicals used in the denim supply chain, there is an obvious potential for businesses to use less harmful chemicals and materials to increase their environmental sustainability quotient. The denim industry has seen an increase in social and environmental responsibility, and businesses in the industry are trying to focus on the new demands of the denim supply chain. Because of this trend, the production of traditional jeans and denim collections requires a different aesthetic and technological approach. 2. LITERATURE REVIEW Denim jeans are massively wasted each year, with 2.16 million metric tons of them ending up mostly in landfills. Haque & Naebe (2022) The widespread fabric known as denim is also one of the most polluting industries in the textile and clothing sector. The second most polluting industry in the world is the denim industry, which is also its most polluting subsector. Many parts of industrial water pollution are caused by the processing and dyeing of textiles, especially denim. Tons of dyes are lost to wastewater each year, while most wastewater in the developing world is discharged directly into rivers. Starting with what gives the fabric its signature indigo
shade, the process of dyeing and finishing jeans is extremely energy and water
intensive. After dyeing, the garments are subjected to various chemical
treatments and washings, including bleaching, to soften, fade or texturize the
fabric. Denim clothes are washed with a
pumice stone. During the procedure, the stone is ground into a powder; some
will remain in the liquor and some will adhere to the
clothing. A significant amount of water is required for many wash cycles to
successfully remove pumice deposits from denim. Pumice dust and rich contribute
to environmental pollution. Silica sand is used in a mechanical finishing
process known as sandblasting. When microscopic silica dust becomes airborne,
it can cause serious respiratory problems such as silicosis. The ethical and denim industries prominently and publicly address the fundamental challenges of sustainability, which are often highlighted in line with the textile and fashion industries. To incorporate best practices into its system, the denim sector has become receptive to discussing denim sector issues. To deal with future difficulties and sustain themselves in creating companies with reduced environmental impacts, companies in the denim sector must reduce the use of resources, especially energy, raw materials, water, and chemicals. The business model must constantly evolve to add value beyond what competitors can provide. They must also understand how society changes over time and take this into account when developing a model in the present. Understanding the current environmental scenario will help the denim sector incorporate it into its new business model. The fact that denim is produced in massive quantities and then thrown away in even greater quantities is one of the major problems facing the industry. Two main effects: create less and produce more efficiently. As less is produced, items can be shared, rented, rented, sold second-hand, and fixed to achieve the same or greater use. Smarter use of resources and recycling of materials minimizes the impact of production on the environment. For example, H&M has launched a program that allows its customers to donate clothes that H&M collects. Neema (2019) Customers can donate their gently worn clothes and get rewards for them, which will help H&M move the process forward. Depending on the condition, the clothes and textiles are subsequently modified using different methods. Textiles are not usually used to make new clothes; they can be recycled into cleaning rags or used as insulating fibres. A separate collaboration between American Eagle and Blue
Jeans Go Green is used. This American company transforms recycled denim and
denim waste into insulation that is used, for example, between the walls of
buildings. Neema (2019) People in the apparel industry are increasingly focusing on sustainability to meet the industry's need to become more sustainable and develop business models that also take sustainability into account as major issues in the industry, such as carbon emissions, water consumption, and potential pollution issues, along with increased customer interest in environmental issues have become more apparent. Holtström et al. (2019) Organizations must improve their internal structure and collaborate with external stakeholders to achieve system-level sustainability. Research Objectives: · to study the processes of manufacturing in the denim industry · to examine some of the business models of the old and modern denim business brands · to develop a sustainable business model 3. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY This study focuses on denim production and its process to make the business sustainable. This research paper is done using descriptive methods. The data collected for analysis comes from several secondary sources. The study examines 50 denim brands, listed as, Hudson Jeans (USA), Diesel (Italy), Sugarcane (Japan), Samurai (Japan), Nudie Jeans (Sweden), Doodlage (India), Tommy Hilfiger (USA), Levi's (USA), Lee Jeans (USA), Wrangler (USA), AG Jeans (USA), 7 For All Mankind (USA), True Religion (USA), Rag & Bone (USA), G-Star RAW (Netherlands), A.P.C. (France), Acne Studios (Sweden), Balmain (France), Evisu (Japan), Big John (Japan), Momotaro Jeans (Japan), Pure Blue Japan (Japan), Iron Heart (Japan), Edwin (Japan), Blue Blue Japan (Japan), Naked & Famous (Canada), Fidelity Denim (Canada), Paige (USA), Joe's Jeans (USA), Citizens of Humanity (USA), Current/Elliott (USA), Frame Denim (USA), J Brand (USA), Bluer Denim (USA), Imogene + Willie (USA), Tellason (USA), Denham (Netherlands), Kings of Indigo (Netherlands), Neuw Denim (Australia), Outland Denim (Australia), Sass & Bide (Australia), Rollas Jeans (Australia), Mavi Jeans (Turkey), Replay (Italy), Pepe Jeans (UK), River Island (UK), Topshop (UK), AllSaints (UK), Zara (Spain), Mango (Spain). Three brands are selected for further research because they incorporate sustainable practices into their business strategy. Other brands were not selected because they do not engage in sustainable work, some do not have evident sustainability measures on their websites, and some we could not reach. Many brands were not selected because they do not actively engage in sustainable practices. Without clear initiatives or commitments to sustainability, these brands do not provide valuable case studies for developing a sustainable business model in the denim industry. For example: True Religion: Limited sustainable practices and lack of comprehensive sustainability strategy. Some brands do not prominently feature their sustainability efforts on their websites, making it difficult to assess their commitment and effectiveness in implementing sustainable practices. Examples include: Balmain: While it might have some sustainable collections, the lack of detailed sustainability information makes it less ideal for study. Certain brands were excluded because information about their sustainability measures was not accessible or they did not respond to inquiries. Examples include: A.P.C.: Despite having high-quality materials and craftsmanship, there is limited public information on their sustainability efforts. The brands chosen for this study were Doodlage, Tommy Hilfiger, and Levi's. Doodlage is an innovative brand that has made significant strides in sustainability by focusing on upcycling and zero-waste production. The brand transforms fabric scraps into fashionable, high-quality garments, thus addressing textile waste head-on. This makes Doodlage an exemplary case of how to integrate circular economy principles into the fashion industry. Tommy Hilfiger has committed to a comprehensive sustainability strategy, including the use of sustainable materials, reducing water and energy consumption, and ensuring ethical labor practices. The brand's global reach and influence make its sustainable practices impactful, and its transparent reporting offers valuable insights into how large-scale operations can be managed sustainably. Levi's is a pioneer in sustainable denim production, known for its Water<Less® technology and participation in the Better Cotton Initiative. The brand's long history and continuous efforts to improve sustainability make it an important model for understanding how legacy brands can innovate and lead in sustainable practices. By selecting Doodlage, Tommy Hilfiger, and Levi's, we focus on brands that not only have clear, impactful sustainability strategies but also provide comprehensive information about their practices. This ensures a robust and informative study that can guide the development of a sustainable business model for the denim industry. Information about these brands is collected from various sources: OCS (Online Clothing Study), issuu, and Business Insider India. 4. LIMITATION In this study, three brands are examined and researched, which is a limitation of the study; if more brands were studied, the paper would be more comprehensive and detailed. This study focuses mainly on the denim industry and its business approach, which is only one type of textile industry among many that can be studied. This research paper is open for future studies where the proposed business model can be explored and tested as the proposed business model is not tested within the industry. Csanák (n.d.-a) 5. FINDINGS 5.1. CASE STUDY-1: Tommy Hilfiger One of the most recognized luxury lifestyle brands, Tommy Hilfiger has been inspiring and motivating people since 1985. Tommy Hilfiger of PVH Corp., a clothing company that "wastes nothing and welcomes everyone," launched Make it Possible. A bold strategy for social and environmental sustainability. Bureau (2020) The brand has set 24 challenging goals for 2030. These goals are divided into four pillars and focus on inclusiveness and circularity. · Circularity: Create something that is perfectly circular and part of a stable loop. · Made for Life: From what they buy to where they sell, they consider and act on global constraints such as climate change, land use, freshwater use, and chemical pollution. · Inclusive: They will remain an inclusive and accessible company for all customers. · Opportunity for All: At Tommy Hilfiger, they remove all barriers to success and provide equitable access to opportunity. More than 80 percent of Tommy Hilfiger's designers have been trained in circular design principles to date, and 72 percent of the cotton used worldwide in 2019 came from greener sources. In addition, two million strands of denim were finished using less water and energy, saving even more resources. This is double the volume of Spring 2020, as evidenced by the 50% increase in sustainable styles planned for Spring 2021. Bureau (2020) Unused buttons from last season's inventory are used to make labels and all sewing threads are made from recycled PET. Bottle. Using advanced laser technology for final washing, each piece of denim uses less water and energy to complete the finishing process. Sarkar (2020) 5.2. CASE STUDY-2: Levi Strauss & Co. Levi Strauss & Co., also known as Levi's, is the world's largest jeans manufacturer, known for its blue denim and eco-friendly jeans. Levi's has set standards for employee safety, ethical behaviour, and respect for the environment. Fashinza. (n.d.) When customers buy jeans, Levi's business strategy for sustainable design encourages them to be more aware that this is not a one-time event. In five major regions, including Germany, the United Kingdom, Canada, the United States, and Japan, Levi's offers a 15 percent discount when consumers donate their used clothing for recycling. Fashinza. (n.d.) This program encourages others to donate used clothes and reduces clothing waste. Levi's supply chain recycles clothing, reduces waste, and creates a safer and healthier environment. The two main effects that can be easily seen are: Saving and recycling water: In addition to saving more than 3.5 billion litres of water in the final stages of the denim production process, we have recycled more than 5 billion litres of water. Processing: They have tumbled jeans with bottle caps and golf balls that completely remove water from the wash and keep 96% of it for finishing, instead of only washing with fabric softener that gives them a worn-in feel. Sarkar (2020) 5.3. CASE STUDY-3: Doodlage Doodlage is the first internet-branded casual wear company founded in 2012 in India with the direct idea of producing superior and unique eco-friendly products. Doodlage has used recycling techniques to transform industrial waste into women's and men's clothing, including repair, reuse, renovation, and recycling. Denim products and more are available in the product catalogue in different shades, patterns, and materials like organic cotton, corn fabric, banana fabric, and more. The main goals they pursue are: · Plastic-free packaging: The company promotes that every product is produced responsibly and all packaging is made without plastic. · Waste Management: Doodlage strives to reduce production waste; what is left over is used to make bags and home decorations. · Healthy collaboration: The company obtains waste fabrics and defective garments from many large companies and other fabric exporters through which it has partnerships. · Sustainable production: They create fabrics for post-consumer waste using certified recycled yarns on both hand and power looms. They do not use substances made with polluted water or materials that contain any chemicals. Therefore, they actively promote waste reduction throughout their operations. Srinivasan (2022) 6. SUGGESTED BUSINESS MODEL Each case study is examined before we arrive at this suggestive Sustainable business model for denim. Figure 1
Table 1
Figure 2
7. RECOMMENDATIONS The given findings help us in learning the sustainable business models of various big brands and help in the suggestive business model for denim start-ups. More and more attention is paid not only to society but also to the environmental impacts of textiles and clothing, especially for certain specific types of products, such as denim clothing. The demand for textiles that are more environmentally friendly is constantly growing and at the same time saves natural resources. With a sustainable business model, brands will have their reputation by improving their environmental and social behaviour. It also builds strong ties between customers and companies by involving them in sustainability initiatives. Technological innovations in terms of denim production and processing will certainly be one of the relevant solutions for the sustainability of denim. The business model should always update in a particular time period so that the company will always balance its production in terms of sustainability. 8. CONCLUSION The primary approach of this research is to provide a sustainable business model in the denim industry. This research consists of three parts and shows a certain view of business development from planning to practical application. The first part focuses on the denim manufacturing process and how it leaves toxic chemicals in the water and pollutes the environment with its impact. The second part includes case studies of three major brands on their sustainable approach. And the third part discusses the development of a detailed suggestive business model for denim companies. Each step, in a given suggestive business model can be seen as a separate or connected opportunity for the denim industry to develop easy sustainable denim production. Denim is known for producing a lot of waste and using water for production, but with this suggestive model, companies can see an alternative in their production process and can easily balance their carbon footprint in nature. Further research is necessary to experiment with a suggestive business model of how the internal organization of established companies responds to these practices, which are similar to the described cases.
CONFLICT OF INTERESTS None. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS None. REFERENCES Arjun, D., Hiranmayee, J., & Farheen, & M. N. (n.d.). MNF Technology of industrial denim washing Technology of Industrial Denim Washing: Review. Bureau, I. R. (2020, September 2). India Retailing Bureau. Retrieved From India Retailing. Accessed on February 2, 2024. Csanák, E. (n.d.-a). Developing a Sustainable Denim Collection: Views, Aspirations & Methods of Ethical Denim. Csanák, E. (n.d.-b). Sustainable Concepts and Eco-Friendly Technologies in the Denim Industry. De Brito, M. P., Carbone, V., & Blanquart, C. M. (2008). Towards a Sustainable Fashion Retail Supply Chain in Europe: Organisation and performance. International Journal of Production Economics, 114(2), 534–553. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijpe.2007.06.012 Fashinza. (n.d.). Levi’s and its Business Guide of Sustainable Fashion and How it has Changed the Industry. Retrieved From Fashinza. Accessed on February 2, 2024. Hamja, A. (2013). Development of Denim; How the Fashion World Looks Into it. Handloomdenim. (n.d.). Retrieved From Slow Made India. Accessed on February 10, 2024. Haque, A. N., & Naebe, M. (2022). Sustainable Biodegradable Denim Waste Composites for Potential Single-Use Packaging. Holtström, J., Bjellerup, C., & Eriksson, J. (2019). Business Model Development for Sustainable Apparel Consumption: The Case of Houdini Sportswear. Journal of Strategy and Management. 12(4). 481–504. Islam, Md. T., & Hassan, Md. N. (2021). The Basic Layout of a Denim Textile Industry: A Basic Review. Journal of Management Science & Engineering Research, 5(1). https://doi.org/10.30564/jmser.v5i1.4068 Jiby, B. (2017). The Indian Denim Industry in a Market Driven Environment. International Journal of Advanced Research, 5(5), 1189–1196. https://doi.org/10.21474/IJAR01/4231 Neema, T. (2019). Denim Production and Sustainable Development Neema Tindwa. Sarkar, P. (2020, July 29). Making Denim & Jeans More Sustainable Way - Initiatives by Top Apparel Brands. Srinivasan, B. (2022, April 25). Doodlage- CSR Activities. Sustainable Denim Finishing. (n.d.). Retrieved From. Accessed on February 10, 2024. Cottonworks.
© ShodhKosh 2024. All Rights Reserved. |